I also write for our sister blog, TVSquad. I review Desperate Housewives, when it's not in re-runs. At the end of the most recent season, one of the characters, Lynnette, played by Felicity Huffman, was diagnosed with what could be Hodgkin's Lymphoma or Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma. They will play out her cancer in the fourth season of the show. At the season finale, she was about to begin chemotherapy. I have been meaning to write about this here, because I think it's a brave and beautiful thing that both the show and the network are choosing a storyline that will be, with any luck, authentic, raw, emotional, and difficult. So, I was dismayed by this comment, by person called 'Spense:'
I'm sorry, but I have no interest in seeing Lynette diagnosed with cancer. It would not be great to see her fight through it, it would just be horribly depressing. Yes, felicity huffman is the actress who could pull it off, but the marriage problems are enough to deal with. It's bad enough that every day you hear of someone else getting cancer. It's just depressing, and to be honest i might stop watching if they do go through with it.
I don't think television producers and writers should shy away from story lines that might be depressing. And this person seems to think that cancer is something that happens to "someone else." None of us are beyond the pale. We could, any of us, be diagnosed any time. I think it is our very vulnerability, paired with the fact that we all do know "someone else" who has been diagnosed with cancer that makes it vital that this storyline be pursued. And I am sorry that viewers will tune out rather than watch a journey that could lead to triumph...or sorrow. I will be riveted-- and I think it would be so cool if all of the housewives decided to shave their heads in solidarity with Lynnette. My friends who have gone through chemo have shaved their heads before beginning, as a marking point, a rite of passage, a ritual: they are going to seize what control they have. It is a dramatic and essential moment. And I think it would be incredibly bold for the show to pursue it.
What do you think: Will the storyline of having a major character on a very popular show deal with cancer make you more or less likely to tune in?











1. I'm about to go through treatment for a recurrence and the last thing I or my family want to see on a TV show is a character with cancer, especially in a twisted, dark comedic fantasy.
TV shows never get medical stuff completely right. In addition, I expect many who watch will falsely assume that this one TV character's fictional experience with cancer must be identical to any person's real experience with cancer, causing harmful misconceptions. The idea of cancer as entertainment is absurd.
Posted at 4:45PM on Jun 27th 2007 by Liz Stevens